So just why you’ll John remain their bisexuality personal?
John are reluctant to obfuscate the situation also this much inside Sherlock’s visibility. John lets Sherlock trust he could be upright, however, the guy never ever closes that home entirely: strange conclusion for a beneficial heterosexual kid, however, positively sensible to own an excellent bisexual guy which is shopping for a love which have Sherlock and dreams Sherlock you are going to alter their mind. Even though John cannot knowingly say “I am not saying gay” within earshot out-of Sherlock, Sherlock does overhear John declare that so you’re able to Irene within the A good Scandal in Belgravia — right after which John attempts to keeps a discussion about this that have Sherlock, and that is turn off.
Really, 
to begin with, Sherlock seemed to most dislike the notion of John are lured to help you him. It makes sense John would just date females to save Sherlock from getting the feeling. Contemplate, John try willing to eliminate individuals remain near Sherlock, very without a doubt however getting willing to mask their sex also. Together with, in the event that John attempted to time people they will guess he had been in search of Sherlock, but not unfairly. It makes one particular sense to possess John up until now lady, and he cannot seem to have a problem with they. (Although, become fair, which have John you could not be sure.) It is easy to possess bisexual people to alive heterosexual existence: many people are heterosexual and assume everyone else is also, thus heterosexual dating possibilities appear without the need to getting wanted aside.
But as to the reasons wasn’t John already discover regarding it, and just why do he obfuscate the challenge to help you his cousin and Expenses Murray? Well, you will find tips so you can more causes within these very early writings records. John is actually known as a people guy prior to getting sent out so you can Afghanistan, along with The hallmark of About three we have been displayed the smoothness of Biggest Sholto, men which John significantly admires and it has a few of the same unsociable features Sherlock has actually; maybe the caretaker when you look at the John are attracted to those who have a look mentally wounded and you will skittish.
While making a joke regarding the proven fact that John might possibly be homosexual was not the most painful and sensitive ecosystem they might keeps built if the John desired to appear
And also in greater conditions, it could be not surprising in the event the John’s gay front concerned the latest fore as he was at the new military and you may mainly surrounded by people — as well as, regarding the Manifestation of Three we are going to be provided with major gay connections into armed forces, and you can Major Sholto specifically. And, the inform you tend to strengthen more often than once you to gender are vital that you John. If the John possess people attraction anyway in order to people, it isn’t unrealistic to think he would act with it when you look at the an enthusiastic environment in which there were couple readily available females.
Many informing procedure, however, is the fact John’s audience of these “I am not saying homosexual” minutes is not Sherlock, actually despite the fact Sherlock consider John are hitting to the him in the first event and individuals continuously imagine these include a couple
So what took place for the Afghanistan? We don’t see, however it is definitely not difficult to speculate. Possibly John did not will work with it, and he does not understand how to identify. Perhaps it absolutely was unrequited, and then he seems sad otherwise bitter considering unsociable boys. Perhaps it actually was requited and finished improperly. Possibly the guy did act in it however, there clearly was pressure to help you ensure that is stays magic and, which have just came back regarding the conflict, he isn’t extremely sure how to go about getting open from the they offered his earlier in the day character and his dated household members are unusual about any of it — perhaps not a rare topic just in case you come-out after in the lives, and you may Expenses and you will Harry appear to select the suggestion comedy. Or at least John informed themselves it had been only because women were not readily available, however, they are just starting to discover maybe it had been more you to. Possibly the guy does favor females, and you may males have to really be a gift. Possibly the guy wishes pupils; John looks pleased adequate when he learns regarding Mary’s maternity inside The sign of Three. It is far from whatsoever unusual to possess bisexual guys to have sex with people however, only go after dating with women thanks to this.
